How it works
When a storm is coming to Kansas City, Storm Check puts what the National Weather Service and the four local TV stations say
about it in one place, follows how their forecasts change as it gets closer, and keeps it all after the storm has passed, next to what
actually happened.
When a storm starts
Storm Check starts following a storm when, for the Kansas City area:
- the Storm Prediction Center puts it in a slight risk (2 of 5) of severe storms or higher, or the Weather Prediction Center in a slight
risk of flooding rain or higher
- the National Weather Service issues a watch, warning or advisory for severe storms, tornadoes, winter weather, ice, flooding or high wind
- the National Weather Service forecasts half an inch of snow or more, or any ice
- the National Weather Service forecasters' discussion names severe storms, snow, ice or flooding as a concern
Days in a row, with at most one quiet day between, count as one storm.
What the stations said
While a storm is coming, we record the morning, midday and evening newscasts of KSHB 41, KMBC 9, KCTV5 and FOX4 off the air and read their closed captions
(where the captions have gaps, the speech is turned into text instead). Each statement about the storm is listed with the time it aired and a
short quote. Every quote is checked word for word against the captions, and quotes the captions garbled are left out.
A statement is credited to a meteorologist only when the newscast makes clear who said it: their name on screen, or said out loud;
otherwise it's credited to the station. Only short quotes appear here, never audio or video. Each station's 7-day numbers come from
KC Weather Check, and the National Weather Service side in plain words from
wxexplained.
After the storm
Once a storm has passed, its page shows what happened: rain or snow, highs and lows and timing from the observations at KCI, the warnings
the National Weather Service issued and the storm reports. The quotes stay, so you can see what everyone said and when, next to how it turned
out. Storm Check lists them side by side; it doesn't score or rank anyone.
Questions
Why are you picking on these poor, defenseless local meteorologists?
We're not. We have nothing but respect for Kansas City's meteorologists, on TV and off. Forecasting weather here is hard, and they do it
every day, often live, and sometimes through the night when storms hit. They provide a valuable service to this community.
Storm Check is here to build on their work: to bring what they say together in one place, make it easier to follow as a storm gets
closer, and add context around each forecast. The "check" is there for that context, and to show the skill that goes into getting a storm
right.
Do you show the newscasts?
No. We record them only to read the captions, and the recordings are deleted once that's done. To see a forecast in full, watch the
station.
Why make all these weather sites?
We work in a very weather sensitive business. We're contractually obligated to implement protocols mitigating the effects of certain
weather conditions. If we don't, bad things happen. (Wrath of God type stuff, forty years of darkness, dogs and cats living together,
etc...)
The comparisons and "checks" on our sites come from tools we've used internally for years. We decided to stop doing those collections
and comparisons manually and build automated systems. That's what you see on our sites. While these sites exist primarily for our own use,
you're free to use them too.